Community Jameel

Abstract: Governments seeking to provide food assistance have a choice between providing in-kind food directly to beneficiaries, or providing vouchers that can be used to purchase food on the market. To understand the differences between these policies, the Government of Indonesia randomly phased in the transition from in-kind delivery of subsidized rice to approximately equivalent vouchers usable to buy rice and eggs across 105 districts comprising over 3.4 million beneficiary households. We find the transition led to substantial changes in the allocation of aid in practice. The vouchers provided concentrated assistance to targeted households, who received 45 percent more assistance in voucher areas than in in-kind districts. As a result, for households in the bottom 15 percent at baseline, poverty fell by 20 percent. Vouchers also allowed households to purchase higher-quality rice, and led to increased consumption of egg-based proteins. We find vouchers have little effect on aggregate rice prices, although we observe modest price increases in remote villages. Overall leakage from the program was not affected, but the administrative costs of benefits delivery substantially fell. In short, the results suggest that the change from in-kind food aid to vouchers led to substantial impacts on poverty through the way it changed how programs were implemented on the ground.

‍

Food vs. Food Stamps: Evidence from an At-Scale Experiment in Indonesia

Details

author(s)

publication date

source

related programme

Link to publication

Tax farming redux: Experimental evidence on performance pay for tax collectors

Lives vs. Livelihoods: The impact of the Great Recession on mortality and welfare

Une brève histoire de l’économie

Fixing forest carbon credits

Is it who you are or what you get? Comparing the impacts of loans and grants for microenterprise development

The Camden Coalition care management program improved intermediate care coordination: A Randomized controlled trial

India’s women’s reservation act: A big win for governance and beyond

Stigma and take-Up of labour market assistance: Evidence from two field experiments

Improving delivery of the social safety net: The role of stigma

The Importance of a helping hand in education and in life

Empowering women facing gender-based violence amid COVID-19 through media campaigns

'We've got you covered'

System-, teacher- and student-level interventions for improving participation in online learning at scale in high schools

Finding the indiscernible poor: Community knowledge as a targeting approach

Come out and play: Public space recovery, social capital and citizen security

The demand for mobility: Evidence from an experiment with Uber riders

Come out and play: public space recovery, social capital and citizen security

Effects of cognitive behavioural therapy and cash transfers on older persons living alone in India

The risk of losing health insurance in the United States is large, and remained so after the Affordable Care Act

Better strategies for saving more: Evidence from three interventions in Chile

Out of the woodwork: Enrolment spillovers in the Oregon health insurance experiment

Depression and loneliness among the elderly poor

Development economics, the future of human behaviour research (January 2022)

Books for children on poverty issues

Handbook on using administrative data for research and evidence-based policy

The challenges of universal health insurance in developing countries: Experimental evidence from Indonesia's national health insurance

Food vs. Food Stamps: Evidence from an At-Scale Experiment in Indonesia

Cooking to save your life

The long term effects of the 'Targeting the Ultra Poor Programme'

Improving female labour force participation in MENA

Health care hotspotting — A randomised, controlled trial

Messages on COVID-19 prevention in India increased symptoms reporting and adherence to preventive behaviours among 25 million recipients with similar effects on non-recipient members of their communities

Unpacking a multi-faceted programme to build sustainable income for the very poor

Good economics for hard times

Up in smoke: The influence of household behaviour on the long-run impact of improved cooking stoves

Running randomised evaluations: A practical guide

Do labour market policies have displacement effects? Evidence from a clustered randomized experiment

Improving police performance in Rajasthan, India: Experimental evidence on incentives, managerial autonomy and training

Corruption in developing countries

Poor economics: A radical rethinking of the way to fight global poverty

La politique de l’autonomie: Lutter contre la pauvreté (Vol 2)

Le développement humain: Lutter contre la pauvreté (Vol 1)

Can voters be primed to choose better legislators? Experimental evidence from Rural India

Medicaid crowd-out of private long-term care insurance demand: Evidence from the health and retirement survey

Making aid work

Social protection in the developing world

Designing a public transit network: Evidence from Jakarta, Indonesia

Policy innovation and experimentation for effective and equitable climate solutions